Why Social Proof is Essential for Recruitment Agencies

Every business has assets. Assets that make the business valuable to its customers.

As a recruitment agency, your main asset is people. You’re in the business of finding the right people (aka candidates) for your clients, who – until the robots take over – are also people. The better you are at finding, attracting and matching people with jobs, the more successful your recruitment agency will be.

It doesn’t need to be emphasized then, how important earning trust is. If your agency is trusted by the candidates and clients that you’ve worked with, then you stand to gain a better quantity and quality of both candidates and clients in the future. This, in turn, leads to an improved industry reputation, and the cycle continues.

When it comes to building trust in your agency, social proof is the most powerful weapon in your marketing arsenal.

What is Social Proof?

How do you decide what to buy online?

How do you pick a doctor?

How do you choose a restaurant? Or a hotel?

In all these scenarios you have a myriad of choices available to you. So, how do you choose?

Maybe you look at industry awards, which tells you what the experts think. Or, maybe you've had a recommendation from someone you trust who's recently had a good experience. Or, perhaps you check online to see what other people have said about the product or service.

There's one common string that ties all of these scenarios together: They all involve some form of social input.

Wikipedia describes social proof as: “A psychological phenomenon wherein people copy the actions of others in an attempt to reflect correct behaviour for a given situation.”

Robert Cialdini, the Professor of Psychology & Marketing who coined the term, goes on to say that social proof “is driven by the assumption that the surrounding people possess more knowledge about the current situation”. Put simply, we rely on the input of others in order to make a decision. It’s like peer pressure, but more scientific.

Social Proof is the reason we look up if everyone else is looking up, it’s the reason we choose a busy restaurant over an empty one, and it’s the reason 90% of people read online reviews before choosing a product or service.

It's a concept inherent to human beings. An inescapable symptom of the human condition. And it’s heavily leveraged in marketing.

Mistrust of Advertising

The modern world is shaped by advertisements. They make up the lion’s share of revenue for most media, be it digital or traditional. And most companies, big and small, dedicate a healthy chunk of their budget to advertising.

It should worry businesses then, to learn that advertisements are becoming increasingly ineffective.

Studies suggest that around 69% of people mistrust company advertisements, with the figure being as high as 84% in millennials. This is a rising trend, with 43% of people claiming to trust advertisements less than they used to.

The reason behind this slow demise of the advertising industry is simple: People do not find advertisements to be genuine. People are less interested in what a business says about itself and more intrigued by what others have to say about it (click to tweet!).

Social Proof: The New World Order

Social Proof has seen a huge spike in interest with the rise of the internet, electronic markets, and particularly social media. These days, social proof is more effective, more accessible, and more important than at any other time in human history.

E-Commerce websites like eBay and Amazon are unbelievably successful largely due to their extensive and transparent review systems. With services like TripAdvisor, Uber, Glassdoor, and Airbnb to name only a few, online reviews are playing a part in every facet of people's lives. And there's no exception for the recruitment industry.

Social Proof for Recruitment Agencies

The best way to demonstrate social proof's importance to recruitment agencies is by example. Let’s take a look at a typical journey for approaching a passive candidate (this can be applied to a client approach too!).

1. You send a message (email, LinkedIn, Facebook message etc.) to a candidate you’ve identified for a role.

2. Assuming the candidate opens your message, it’s highly likely their next step will be to do some research (perhaps even before reading the content of the message itself). They’ll probably look at your website and your LinkedIn profile, they may even look you up on Google to see what else they can find.

And what is it that the candidate is looking for? Social Proof.

Whether or not that candidate replies to your message will be massively influenced by the results of their research into you and your agency.

If their research unveils bad reviews, or an out-of-date website without any testimonials or live jobs, or no website at all (!), or an empty LinkedIn profile, the list goes on; then the chances are you'll never hear back from them. To rub salt in the wound, they could even decide to apply to your client directly (if you've let slip who the company is). Afterall, why should they trust you to manage their career given what others are saying?

On the other hand, if the candidate's research is met with positive ratings and reviews from other candidates that have used your service, then their perception will be positive. They'll trust you. Even if the job you've approached them about isn't of interest, you've greatly increased your chances of starting a relationship.

Simply put, it's essential to build trust in that early 'research'. If you're unable to do so, you're 100% losing out.

Reviews Lead The Way

Online social proof comes in many forms, but arguably the most powerful is reviews.

Having a transparent, extensive, and preferably third party review system makes both candidates and clients trust in your recruitment agency.

The perception of reliability and transparency will not only help to convert website traffic, it will also help to increase the volume of that traffic. Businesses with reviews integrated into their organic search results have been found to do as much as 35% better on their click-through rate.

Preferrd is a reviews platform built solely for recruitment agencies. Our reviews widgets are built specifically to help agencies display social proof and integrate their reviews into search results via rich snippets.

Get in touch with our marketing team today for a free consultation on how social proof can help your agency.

Interested in Preferrd?

Schedule a call with our team to find out how real candidate & client reviews can supercharge your business.
Schedule a Free Demo